Medicare Supplements are Complicated

We’re Here To Help

Personal Guidance

Medicare Supplement plans are designed to cover the out-of-pocket costs that Original Medicare doesn’t, including copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles. Choosing the right plan can be complex, as each plan has unique coverage options, from standardized benefits to costs that vary by state and provider. Schmitt Insurance agents Justin Schmitt and Leighton Schmitt, with decades of experience, offer free consultations to help you find a plan that fits your specific health and financial needs. As an independent agency, they advocate solely for you, ensuring unbiased recommendations across multiple providers. With Schmitt Insurance, you’re supported by knowledgeable, dedicated experts who understand the intricacies of Medigap options. Let them help you select the best coverage for peace of mind in your healthcare journey.

Here’s How It Works

Step 1 - Schedule An Appointment

Give us a call, or send a message. We’ll set a time to answer your questions and explain your options.

Step 2 - Get Expert, Unbiased Advice

We’ll give you our recommendation based on years of experience helping thousands of people just like you. Once you select a plan, we’ll make the enrollment process quick and easy.

Step 3 - Relax

Take a deep breath and go back to enjoying your life without the pressure of making the wrong Medicare decision. We’re only ever a call away if you need any help.

Client Testimonials

Why So Many Trust Us For Their Coverage

Leighton has gone above and beyond to find insurance that fits my needs and budget. There is no pressure.

I highly recommend speaking with this people oriented agency for your insurance needs.

- Dave N.

I contacted Leighton regarding changing my Medicare Supplement on a recommendation from one of his clients & was glad I did. He spent time explaining the different plans, insurance companies, & rates. The result was a considerable savings over my current plan. Thank you Leighton!

- Nanci W.

I can't say enough good things about Schmitt Insurance. I am a client of Justin Schmitt and he has walked me through all the confusion regarding Medicaid/Medicare and so thankful that he did!

- Brooke C.


Phone: (574) 544-6600
Fax: (574) 544-5550


Office Address:
4560 S Ironwood Dr
South Bend, IN. 46614


Office Hours:
9am - 5pm Monday-Friday

Please call or message for an appointment. After hours and Saturday meetings are available

Our South Bend Office

4560 S Ironwood Drive, South Bend

Driving Directions:

We’re on Ironwood south of Ireland Road and just north of the bypass, on the east side of the road. Turn onto the side street called Lamar to park behind the building. The entrance is a big orange door.

We’d Love to Help!

Call or use the form below and we’ll be in touch!

By submitting the information above, you agree to be contacted by a licensed sales agent by email or phone to discuss information about Medicare or other insurance options. This is a solicitation for insurance.

This information will be used solely by Schmitt Insurance, and will not be distributed or sold to 3rd parties.