Voted Best Insurance Agent

In the South Bend Tribune Readers’ Choice Awards 2023 & 2022


Schmitt Insurance is proud to serve over 1600 clients in Indiana and Michigan. We specialize in Medicare, Long-Term Care Planning, and Safe Money Places. Our goal is to help find the best plan for your needs, period.

Agents Justin Schmitt and Leighton Schmitt

Justin Schmitt & Leighton Schmitt

We Are Independent and Unbiased

As an independent agency, we represent over 30 top insurance companies. Independence allows us to work for you, not the insurers. We help find the plan that works best for you, period.

Our Service is Absolutely Free

Many clients are surprised to learn our service is absolutely free. Nothing. Nada. No fine print.

We get paid by the insurance companies to help you. Policies cost exactly the same whether you work with us or sign up directly. By choosing us you’ll get a dedicated agent focused on your specific needs. And since we build long-term relationships, you can count on service for years to come. So choose the help of a pro.

Award Winning Service

We don’t like to brag, but we are deeply proud to have won Best Insurance Agent in the South Bend Tribune Readers Choice Awards For 2023 and 2022. Thanks everyone for your support!


Client Testimonials

Why So Many Trust Us For Their Coverage

Leighton has gone above and beyond to find insurance that fits my needs and budget. There is no pressure.

I highly recommend speaking with this people oriented agency for your insurance needs.

- Dave N.

Leighton is an excellent insurance agent providing information and service and extremely fast response times well above my expectations.

- Bruce P.

I recently was given some advice from Leighton Schmitt on buying my prescriptions. I was pleasantly surprised when I purchased the prescriptions, and the cost was lower than I expected. It does not usually happen that way.

- Henry Q.

Leighton Schmitt has helped me over the past years, with very difficult and immediate health insurance needs. He was willing to meet on little notice in emergency situations, and was always professional and knowledgeable.

Leighton has a gracious and open demeanor that inspires trust and calm. Besides his excellent character, he has a brilliant mind and is a gifted musician.

I have tremendous regard for this young man professionally and personally.

- Sheri S.

Leighton was very thorough when assessing my needs and finding the right solution for my Medicare supplement plan.

- Stewart S.

Leighton is very helpful, and a very nice man.

- Gary B.

Leighton is the best insurance agent I have worked with. He recently helped me switch from an employer plan to a Medicare Advantage plan. Leighton explained my options and helped me select a plan that best suits my needs. He made understanding Medicare easy.

When a Social Security mistake caused a snag in my approval, Leighton went above and beyond to provide, not only resolution of the problem but also the best customer service I have ever experienced. I highly recommend Schmitt Insurance to anyone for Medicare plans, an annuity or any other insurance policy. Thank you Leighton. I am so blessed to have you on my team.

- Valerie M.

After working with Schmitt Insurance my experience far exceeded my expectations. Professionalism and thorough explanation of services gave me confidence I was doing business with a great insurance company. Thank you Leighton!

- Denise C.

Our Services

 

Medicare

Medicare is confusing. We educate, help clients find the right plan, and avoid common mistakes

Business and Family

Helping families, college students, and small businesses navigate the ACA, and it’s alternatives

Life Insurance

Leave a legacy, cover final expenses or fund a buy-sell agreement

 

Long-Term Care Planning

7 in 10 seniors will need LTC. A LTC Plan helps protect you, your estate, and your preference for dignified care

Safe Money Places

We specialize in annuities which guarantee your principal, offer fair returns, and can provide an income you can't outlive

Even More

We’ve got you covered for Dental, Vision, Disability, Cancer, Accident, and More